Updated: November 7, 2026
Table of contents

A laser can place a droplet accurately and still deliver the wrong number of cells. The droplet might contain none, one, or several cells; the distribution may also change as the donor film ages. For engineers accustomed to powders and slurries, these are recognizable problems of particle statistics, suspension stability, and material consistency.
Laser-induced forward transfer (LIFT) is a nozzle-free printing method. A laser pulse drives a small volume of bioink from a donor film onto a receiving surface. The bioink can contain cells, polymers, and other constituents, so its behavior is determined by the suspension as well as by the laser. Experimental studies show that introducing living cells changes LIFT jetting and deposition behavior [1, 2]. The cell suspension itself is therefore an important part of print reproducibility.
Cells Are Particles in a Suspension
Why cell settling can change a print
A cell suspended in a liquid is subject to gravity, buoyancy, and viscous resistance. For a dilute suspension of approximately spherical cells in a Newtonian liquid, Stokes’ law provides a first estimate of terminal settling velocity:
vₛ = Δρgd² / (18μ)
Here, Δρ is the density difference between the cell and the liquid, g is gravitational acceleration, d is cell diameter, and μ is liquid dynamic viscosity. Settling speed increases with the square of cell diameter and falls as viscosity rises. Large cells and aggregates can therefore redistribute much faster than smaller individual cells. In the common inverted LIFT arrangement, the donor bioink hangs beneath the laser-absorbing layer, with its free surface facing the receiver. Cells denser than the carrier liquid therefore settle away from the absorbing layer and toward that free surface. Over a print run, this redistribution can change the cell population available for transfer.
This matters because LIFT samples a thin film rather than an infinitely mixed reservoir. If cells redistribute relative to the transfer region during a run, the local concentration can diverge from the concentration measured when the ink was prepared. A stable droplet footprint can conceal a changing cell population. The same variables appear in PTI’s sedimentation guide: particle size, density contrast, fluid viscosity, concentration, and interactions.
Stokes’ law is most useful as a screening estimate. Cell shape, deformation, hindered settling, adhesion, and any yield-stress network can change the actual rate. The appropriate follow-up is straightforward: image or count cells at relevant positions in the donor film at the start and end of printing. Studies of inkjet bioinks have directly observed sedimentation-driven concentration gradients and aggregation during hold time [3]. Those reservoir results establish the mechanism, although the geometry and residence time differ from LIFT donor films.
Why identical droplets contain different numbers of cells
Even a well-dispersed bioink does not place exactly one cell into every droplet. At low concentrations, cells are distributed statistically. If cells are randomly and independently dispersed, the expected number per droplet is:
λ = C × V
where C is cells per unit liquid volume and V is droplet volume, expressed in matching units. The probability of finding k cells in a droplet follows the Poisson distribution:
P(k) = e−λ λᵏ / k!
This is not merely a theoretical analogy. Using fixed NIH 3T3 fibroblasts, Bosmans and colleagues counted cells in LIFT droplets across different cell concentrations and found distributions that closely matched Poisson predictions under their tested conditions [4]. Their work shows how cell concentration and transferred volume can be used to plan the fraction of empty, single-cell, and multicell droplets.
The statistics also reveal a control trade-off. Increasing cell concentration reduces empty droplets, but it increases the frequency of droplets containing several cells. Moreover, aggregates violate the assumption that individual cells are independently dispersed. If measured cell counts depart from the Poisson baseline, inspect local concentration drift, clustering, and transferred-volume variation instead of treating the discrepancy as random noise. PTI’s dispersion and suspension-stability guide provides the corresponding particle-behavior framework.
Cell loading changes rheology and jetting
Cells also alter the mechanical behavior of the carrier fluid. In a simple rigid-sphere suspension, the Krieger-Dougherty relation describes how relative viscosity increases with particle volume fraction:
ηᵣ = (1 − φ/φₘ)−[η]φₘ
Here, φ is particle volume fraction, φₘ is the limiting packing fraction, and [η] is intrinsic viscosity. For ideal rigid spheres, [η] is often taken as 2.5 [5]. Cells are deformable, their carrier may be shear-thinning or viscoelastic, and cell clusters can have a larger effective volume than isolated cells. Therefore, the relation describes the direction and possible sensitivity of the loading effect, not a calibrated cell-bioink viscosity prediction.
The process evidence is stronger than a fitted equation alone. Zhang and colleagues compared cell-free and cell-laden alginate bioinks during LIFT. Adding cells raised the transfer threshold while reducing jet velocity, breakup length, and deposited droplet size at comparable laser conditions. They also observed non-straight jet trajectories associated with local heterogeneity in the cell-containing ink [1]. Kryou and colleagues subsequently examined how cell concentration, laser fluence, and donor-to-receiver distance affect LIFT jet and droplet formation [2].
For a printability investigation, measure cell concentration and aggregation alongside the complete flow curve, rather than reporting polymer viscosity without the cells. PTI’s viscosity overview and liquid-phase and dispersion test methods help distinguish apparent viscosity, yield stress, shear response, and settling stability.
How Laser-Induced Forward Transfer Couples Material and Process Conditions
Laser energy is not the only determinant
In a common LIFT setup, a short laser pulse reaches an absorbing layer between the transparent donor substrate and the bioink film. The resulting pressure drives a jet toward the receiver. Depending on the energy and material conditions, the liquid may not transfer, may form a well-defined jet, or may form unstable jets and unwanted satellite droplets [1, 2, 6].
Yusupov and colleagues tested cell-free hyaluronic acid, methylcellulose, and alginate hydrogels with a 1064 nm, 8 ns laser and a 30 µm spot. In that setup, their reported single-droplet regimes fell around 2 to 3 J/cm², with formulation-dependent boundaries [6]. Zhang and colleagues investigated cell-laden alginate under a different configuration and observed well-defined transfer at substantially different fluences [1]. The useful engineering lesson is to construct a process map for the actual ink and laser rather than copy a nominal fluence value.
Three dimensionless groups help organize measurements:
- Ohnesorge number, Oh = μ / √(ρσd): viscosity relative to inertia and surface tension.
- Weber number, We = ρv²d / σ: inertia relative to surface tension.
- Reynolds number, Re = ρvd / μ: inertia relative to viscosity.
The variables are density ρ, surface tension σ, representative diameter d, velocity v, and dynamic viscosity μ. These groups are especially useful when comparing runs with different droplet sizes or rheological conditions. For viscoelastic inks, a single viscosity cannot capture the entire stress response. Jet breakup and receiver impact still need to be observed, not inferred solely from a dimensionless number.
A donor film is a changing feed material
LIFT combines two time-dependent material problems: the film may lose water, and its cell population may redistribute. Both can change what is transferred later in a run.
Yusupov and colleagues measured viscosity changes between 20 and 24°C: approximately 20 to 18 mPa·s for their 2% hyaluronic acid solution and 231 to 194 mPa·s for their 1% methylcellulose solution [6]. They also reported more than 60% mass loss over 30 minutes from approximately 200 µm films held at 20°C and 50% relative humidity. Their stated thinning rate of roughly 8 µm/min describes the observed drying behavior; it should not be extrapolated as a constant rate across the full 30 minutes.
Drying changes film thickness and fluid concentration, while settling can change cell density at the transfer position. If droplet volume drifts, measure film thickness and rheology. If droplet size stays stable but cell counts drift, examine cell distribution. If both change, the mechanisms may be coupled. These three possibilities suggest different measurements and avoid needless changes to laser energy.
For particle-size measurements, the relevant question is likewise the population that the process actually encounters. Cell size and aggregate counts should be resolved with appropriate microscopy or single-particle methods rather than inferred from a single ensemble average. PTI’s particle size and morphology test-methods guide explains why number-based distributions, tail populations, and sample state matter.
Granular Bioinks: Where Packing and Jamming Apply Directly
Hydrogel microparticles form a granular material
Not all bioprinting inks are continuous polymer solutions. Granular bioinks contain individual hydrogel microparticles, commonly called microgels, packed within a fluid or softer matrix. Their properties depend on microgel size distribution, shape, deformability, particle contacts, volume fraction, and interactions [7]. This is a genuine granular-material problem.
As packing fraction rises, microgels increasingly constrain one another. A jammed assembly can exhibit yield stress: it holds a shape under weak stress and flows when sufficient stress is applied. Its flow and recovery after deformation depend on contact networks, deformation, and the properties of the interstitial phase. These are measurable with oscillatory and steady-shear rheology, yield-stress tests, and microscopy. A single viscosity measurement does not adequately describe the transition.
Daly’s review of granular hydrogels identifies microgel morphology, packing density, and stiffness as influential variables for printability and cellular responses [7]. Mukundan and colleagues demonstrated a jammed agarose-microgel ink and investigated how particle assembly and interparticle bonding support printed-structure integrity [8]. These are particle assemblies in which microgel contacts and packing contribute directly to macroscopic behavior.
What particle size distribution can and cannot predict
A broad microgel size distribution may allow smaller particles to occupy gaps between larger ones, changing the packed structure. Farr and Groot’s hard-sphere model provides a useful geometric reference for how size distribution can affect dense packing [9]. Real microgels also compress, swell, interpenetrate, and develop adhesive contacts, so maximum hard-sphere packing density is not itself a yield-stress or porosity prediction.
The practical variables are nevertheless familiar: the number-based and volume-based size distributions, fraction of aggregates, effective particle volume fraction, interstitial fluid, and deformation under shear. These determine whether a microgel assembly can be delivered, retain its shape, and create useful interstitial spaces. Compare each formulation at a controlled preparation, shear, and rest history before evaluating printed geometry.
Much of the granular-bioink evidence comes from extrusion and embedded bioprinting, not direct LIFT deposition. Granular inks show where powder and particle engineering already plays a central role in bioprinting, while transferring a given granular formulation through LIFT requires its own jetting study.
Worked Example: From Cell Concentration to Droplet Composition
What does a 0.17 nL droplet actually deliver?
Bosmans and colleagues estimated a transferred volume of approximately 0.17 nL at 5 µJ laser energy and 1 mm donor-to-receiver distance using fixed NIH 3T3 fibroblasts in their cell-distribution study [4]. Use that volume with a nominal bioink concentration of 5 × 10⁶ cells/mL. The volume is 1.7 × 10⁻⁷ mL, giving:
λ = (5 × 10⁶ cells/mL) × (1.7 × 10⁻⁷ mL) = 0.85 cells per droplet
For randomly and independently suspended cells:
| Cell count in one droplet | Poisson probability |
|---|---|
| No cells | 42.7% |
| Exactly one cell | 36.3% |
| Two or more cells | 20.9% |
These percentages are calculated, not measured. For a pattern requiring exactly one cell at each position, even perfectly repeatable droplet ejection leaves a substantial occupancy problem. For multicell deposition, a different concentration may be appropriate. Select concentration against the desired occupancy distribution, then count actual printed cells to see whether the model describes the process.
How quickly might cells redistribute?
Consider an illustrative suspension containing 15 µm cells, with a 30 kg/m³ density difference relative to the liquid and 10 mPa·s viscosity. Stokes’ law gives approximately 0.37 µm/s, or 22 µm/min. The nominal time to travel 200 µm is therefore around nine minutes under unobstructed, free-settling conditions. This is a scale estimate for deciding whether donor-film aging deserves measurement, not a measured settling rate for the Bosmans bioink. Yield stress, cells interacting with the donor surface, and film geometry could alter it considerably.
Now connect the two calculations. If sedimentation increases local cell concentration during printing, λ rises even if the transferred volume remains constant. If drying changes transferred volume, λ changes even if concentration remains constant. Cell count per droplet responds to both. Monitoring volume alone or average cell concentration alone can miss the cause of a changing occupancy distribution.
Where do the jetting numbers fit?
A spherical droplet with volume 0.17 nL has an equivalent diameter of approximately 69 µm. To illustrate force ratios, assume a velocity of 2 m/s, a density of 1,000 kg/m³, a surface tension of 45 mN/m, and a viscosity of 10 mPa·s. These are deliberately specified calculation inputs, not measured values attributed to Bosmans and colleagues.
The resulting approximate values are We = 6.1, Oh = 0.18, and Re = 14. They identify a regime in which viscosity and surface tension merit attention during impact. They do not tell us how many cells are present or whether the receiver will support cell attachment. Those outcomes require occupancy measurements, deposited-footprint imaging, and biological assays. The example therefore separates three linked but distinct questions: what volume is transferred, how many cells it contains, and what happens when it lands.
Which Measurements Separate the Causes of Print Drift?
The most useful control plan links a visible change to a discriminating measurement. A single symptom may have several physical causes.
| Observation | First mechanism to test | Discriminating evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Cell counts per droplet change, footprint stable | Cell redistribution or aggregation | Spatial/time-resolved cell counts and aggregate microscopy |
| Droplet size changes with elapsed print time | Donor drying or rheology drift | Film thickness, temperature, humidity, flow curve |
| Jets become asymmetric or depart from intended trajectory | Local suspension heterogeneity or altered jetting | High-speed imaging, cell/aggregate distribution, laser settings |
| Satellites increase at comparable ink composition | Change in transfer regime | Fluence, donor thickness, transfer imaging |
| Deposited cells survive poorly despite regular droplets | Receiver impact or biological stress | Receiver comparison, immediate and delayed viability assays |
| A granular bioink loses shape after delivery | Insufficient jamming, recovery, or particle bonding | Yield stress, recovery time, microgel size distribution, structure after setting |
For LIFT, record the transferred droplet distribution together with cell concentration, donor age, and the location sampled in the film. Bosmans and colleagues provide a contemporary example of combining droplet metrics and cell-count statistics within a printability framework [4]. For granular inks, add packing-related measurements and rheological recovery rather than treating print fidelity as a function of delivery settings alone.
Biological performance remains an independent endpoint. Even when transfer is repeatable, receiver material affects post-printing viability. In separate live-cell experiments, Bosmans and colleagues reported 97% viability for endothelial cells printed onto fibrin hydrogels on days 1 and 3, whereas viability on uncoated plastic fell to 5% by day 3 under their tested conditions [4]. Measure viability and relevant cell function rather than using a regular droplet pattern as their surrogate.
Conclusion: Where Particle Technology Makes a Difference
The clearest connection between powder technology and laser-assisted bioprinting lies inside the droplet, not in treating the droplet as a dry grain. Suspended cells settle, aggregate, alter rheology, and enter transferred volumes according to measurable population statistics. Those mechanisms affect the composition and repeatability of the print, sometimes before the deposited pattern visibly deteriorates.
Granular microgel bioinks establish a second, more direct connection. Their structure and flow arise from particle size, packing, contacts, and jamming. Together, these examples show that particle technology contributes more than an analogy: it supplies tools for predicting occupancy, diagnosing material drift, designing suspension measurements, and understanding the mechanics of jammed bioinks. The next experiment becomes more informative when it starts with the particle population actually being printed.
Frequently asked questions
References
- Zhang, Z., Xu, C., Xiong, R., Chrisey, D. B., and Huang, Y. (2017). Effects of living cells on the bioink printability during laser printing. Biomicrofluidics, 11, 034120.
- Kryou, C., Theodorakos, I., Karakaidos, P., Klinakis, A., Hatziapostolou, A., and Zergioti, I. (2021). Parametric Study of Jet/Droplet Formation Process during LIFT Printing of Living Cell-Laden Bioink. Micromachines, 12, 1408.
- Xu, H., Martinez Salazar, D. M., and Xu, C. (2022). Investigation of Cell Concentration Change and Cell Aggregation Due to Cell Sedimentation during Inkjet-Based Bioprinting of Cell-Laden Bioink. Machines, 10, 315.
- Bosmans, C., et al. (2026). A Quantitative Printability Framework for Programmable Assembly of Pre-Vascular Patterns via Laser-Induced Forward Transfer. Advanced Healthcare Materials, 15, e03665.
- Krieger, I. M., and Dougherty, T. J. (1959). A Mechanism for Non-Newtonian Flow in Suspensions of Rigid Spheres. Transactions of the Society of Rheology, 3, 137–152.
- Yusupov, V., et al. (2020). Laser-induced Forward Transfer Hydrogel Printing: A Defined Route for Highly Controlled Process. International Journal of Bioprinting, 6, 271.
- Daly, A. C. (2024). Granular Hydrogels in Biofabrication: Recent Advances and Future Perspectives. Advanced Healthcare Materials, 13, e2301388.
- Mukundan, L. M., et al. (2024). Photo-annealable agarose microgels for jammed microgel printing: Transforming thermogelling hydrogel to a functional bioink. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules, 278, 134550.
- Farr, R. S., and Groot, R. D. (2009). Close packing density of polydisperse hard spheres. Journal of Chemical Physics, 131, 244104.




